CFTC’s New Chair Moves to Modernize Rules as Prediction Markets Hang in the Balance
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chairman Michael Selig has proclaimed that U.S. financial markets are entering a "golden age." He said the CFTC has a "generational opportunity" to future-proof and modernize its regulatory approach.
He made these comments in a Washington Post op-ed on Tuesday as he launched a new “Future-Proof” initiative.
In a televised interview with Fox Business the same day, Selig framed the moment as a “pivotal” shift. It’s driven by emerging technologies, including blockchain, artificial intelligence, cloud computing, and prediction markets.
The initiative will review and update outdated rules that regulators wrote decades ago for agricultural futures contracts.
Selig said that these rules don’t cover some of the more recent innovations in the financial sector. He noted that the CFTC needs to “upgrade its approach to unleash innovation” amid the rise of AI and blockchain technology.
The CFTC will comprehensively review all regulations to identify where the agency needs to update its rules for the modern era.
He argued that regulators must work collaboratively with builders and entrepreneurs rather than impose prescriptive, top-down requirements that fail to reflect how modern financial infrastructure is actually developed.
In his op-ed and subsequent interview, Selig criticized past regulatory approaches that subjected emerging products, such as digital assets, to legacy frameworks. He argued that these frameworks failed to reflect how modern financial markets operate.
Selig promised that the CFTC would be “charting a new course” under his leadership.
CFTC on the Fence About Prediction Markets
Prediction markets emerged as one of the examples Selig cited of how rapidly the futures and derivatives landscape is evolving. In the Fox Business interview, he grouped them alongside blockchain and digital assets as a growing market that now falls squarely within the CFTC’s regulatory remit.
Since his official appointment in December, he has said very little publicly about the topic. When Senator Tina Smith asked him during his November confirmation hearing whether the CFTC would take action against prediction markets, he was noncommittal. Selig said he would follow whatever approach the courts saw fit for the space.
The CFTC’s January 8 decision not to take enforcement action against the Bitnomial Exchange was telling. It chose not to enforce rules against the platform, which offers non-sports prediction markets. This was despite failures to comply with the required swap data reporting rules and to maintain sufficient records.
The CFTC’s approach signals that the agency is willing to keep prediction markets within federal derivatives supervision, rather than treat them as unlawful gambling products, subject to state laws.
A Big Win for State Authorities on Tuesday
The prediction market landscape is on a precipice, as several high-profile legal cases continue. States and tribes across the country are taking the fight to operators.
Notably, on Tuesday, the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office secured a court order blocking Kalshi from offering sports markets in the state. This marked the first time a state got an injunction against an operator.
Up until now, it was mainly operators like Kalshi that sought injunctions against state regulators to stay live while legal action was ongoing. Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell emphasized this legal victory on X:
Selig’s recent comments suggest the CFTC may ultimately favor a more permissive, federally supervised framework for emerging markets. He reiterated that innovation should be developed and regulated in the U.S. rather than driven offshore by regulatory uncertainty.
How federal agencies and state regulators resolve their issues will determine whether platforms like Polymarket and Kalshi can continue operating in the U.S. or face tighter constraints in the coming months and years.
Gambling Insider delivers the latest industry news, in-depth features, and operator reviews that you can trust. Our team combines rigorous editorial standards with decades of specialized expertise to ensure accuracy and fairness. We are committed to delivering clear, impartial, and dependable coverage across the global gambling sector.
